Showing posts with label Recurrent miscarriage. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Recurrent miscarriage. Show all posts

Friday, January 13, 2017

Luteal Start Vaginal Micronized Progesterone ups the rate of ongoing pregnancy in RPL.



vaginal micronized progesterone

Recurrent pregnancy loss (RPL) is one of the most traumatic and frustrating experience for patients and consulting obstetricians. It is an area of obstetrics lacking in evidence based diagnostic and treatment strategies. As per data by American Society for Reproductive Medicine(ASRM) it affects 15-25% of all pregnancies and in nearly 50% of cases the cause is not known.


Courtesy:Dr.Malpani Blog

Therapeutic interventions are generally based on the cause of RPL and data from observational studies and clinical experiences of the treating obstetrician. Treatment options range from active interventions in the form of hormonal supplementation to masterly inactivity (= reassurance).[i]

Progesterone (P) has long been used in the treatment of infertility because of its immunomodulator action on endometrium but it’s use is largely empirical along with other treatment regimen.  Cochrane review and meta-analysis concluded that P supplementation could improve the reproductive outcome in women with 3 or more pregnancy loss.

But, in none of these studies P was started after LH surge (luteal start) and varied route and dosing of P administration was used. [ii]

A new study published on line on January 9, 2017 in Fertility & Sterility international journal of the American Society for Reproductive Medicine assessed the effectiveness of luteal start vaginal micronized P in a recurrent pregnancy loss (RPL) cohort.

In this observational, cohort study 116 women with a history of RPL were recruited and followed prospectively. Vaginal micronized progesterone was supplemented in dose of 100–200 mg every 12 hours starting 3 days after LH surge (luteal start corresponding to day 13 of the cycle) with or without >20% increase in levels of nuclear cyclin E (nCyclinE) expression. The controls did not receive P and had normal nCyclinE (≤20%). P was continued till 10 weeks of pregnancy.

The research team lead by Dr. Mary D. Stephenson tested Nuclear cyclin E (nCyclinE) levels to assess the state of endometrium. It is an endometrial molecular marker(EFT) and a cell cycle regulator, levels more than 20% after day 20 of the menstrual cycle correlates with a history of infertility. NCyclinE expression was determined by an EB was performed 9–11 days after the LH surge in previous cycle.

Of 116 women tested, 59 had high levels of nCyclinE and 57 had normal levels.
The results of the test were very promising with 68% pregnancy rate in study group as compared to women who did not take P. The chances of successful pregnancy increased from 6% to 69% in treatment group.

Six women needs to be treated with P to achieve one additional successful pregnancy.( Number need to treat). 

This observational study cannot establish causality, the researchers believe that P is beneficial in changing the endometrial milieu and benefitting the developing embryo.   

Dr. Stephenson said “The positive results show us that next we need to study progesterone as a treatment for recurrent pregnancy loss with a prospective randomized trial to validate the findings." 





[i] http://blog.drmalpani.com/2016/08/pgs-for-recurrent-pregnancy-loss-forget.html
[ii] Haas, M.D. and Ramsey, P.S. Progestogen for preventing miscarriage. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2013;: CD003511

Wednesday, February 24, 2016

Large randomized trial does not support the use of progesterone in recurrent miscarriage.



Recurrent miscarriage affects about 1% of all women of child bearing age.

50% of all early pregnancy loss are due to chromosomal aberration, most common being aneuploidy.  

Progestogens play an important role in implantation, cytokine balance, natural killer cell activity, arachidonic acid release and myometrial contractility. It is secreted by corpus luteum till 7-8 weeks, when the function is taken over by developing placenta. Lack of progesterone support in the luteal phase increases the chances of early pregnancy loss; hence progesterone is often used specially in women with history of recurrent pregnancy loss!

Results of a recent large RCT published in the November issue of  New England Journal of Medicine concluded that Progesterone Doesn't Improve Outcomes After Recurrent Miscarriages.

This large multicenter, double-blind, placebo-controlled, randomized trial recruited 1568 women aged 18-39 years with a history of three or more consecutive or nonconsecutive first-trimester pregnancy losses. Women with anatomical, medical or hematological causes that explain the reason behind miscarriages were excluded from the study.

The study group (n=404) were assigned to receive 400mg of vaginal micronized progesterone , while the control group ( n=432) received a similar looking placebo as soon as the pregnancy were confirmed till 12 weeks of naturally conceived pregnancy.

The live birth rate in progesterone group was 65.8% vs. 63.3% in placebo group. The rate of ectopic pregnancy, congenital anomalies, miscarriage and still birth rates were also comparable in both the groups.  

A Cochrane review in 2013 based on smaller number of trials and subject reported lower rate of miscarriage with progesterone support. This large RCT lead us to a different conclusion.

Management of women with RPL is a challenge in itself, as these women are very anxious and apprehensive and ask for some form of ‘therapy’ to avert a loss again. Over the years many other modalities like heparin, aspirin and acupuncture have been evaluated with mixed results.

There are many unanswered question in therapy of RPL, including the definition of RPL, the evaluation and the timing of starting treatment. Progesterone is an important part of regimen offered, being having endometrial supportive and immune-modulating effects.
Different studies have come up with different results; the study also differed in patient population, mode and type of progesterone and the initiation of treatment since pregnancy confirmation.

Whatever the results and conclusions of different trials may be, the psychological and placebo effect of the progesterone cannot be overlooked for patients who have a high level of anxiety and are afraid of another loss.


References: